
★★★★☆
Vatnik Soup. The Ultimate Guide to Russian Disinformation by Pekka Kallioniemi
A “Vatnik” is a person who believes or spreads Russian propaganda. This book is a freak show with mini-biographies of the 100 most prominent purveyors of Russian propaganda globally. Delves into each vatnik’s motives for spreading Russian narratives or anti-western conspiracy theories. This collection of mini biographies is an excellent antidote to Russian propaganda.
bookshelves: debunking, e-books, politics, russia, ukraine
Highlights
The events that took place in Donbas were meticulously planned and scripted. One could even compare it to a theatrical play with a skilled director, heavy-handed producers, obedient actors, widespread promotion, and marketing. Most important of all, it began to attract an enthralled audience. In the director’s seat sat Vladimir Putin’s former advisor, Vladislav Surkov. Donbas became the stage of his blend of theatre and politics, but the whole script was revealed to us when Ukrainian hackers leaked thousands of his e-mails. Surkov’s background was in avant-garde theatre, and he was an excellent dramaturge.
— location: 147 ^ref-58637
Journalist and author Elena Gorokhova has defined vranyo as follows: Someone lies to us, we know that they’re lying, they know that we know, and they keep on lying anyway, while we pretend to believe them. Vranyo is a kind of tactical lie that continues to shape Russia’s disinformation strategy.
— location: 250 ^ref-55198
By January 2021, Trump had lied more than 30,000 times during his four years in office6. This amounts to approximately 21 lies per day.
— location: 277 ^ref-46782
Conspiracy theories explain events as being orchestrated by powerful, often hidden groups of people. They are often political in nature and rely on insufficient evidence.
— location: 299 ^ref-64488
Conspiracy researcher Michael Barkun has divided conspiracy theories into three distinct categories: Event conspiracies – like the Kennedy assassination or 9/11, systemic conspiracies – like Freemasons or the World Economic Forum running the world – and superconspiracies like QAnon, David Icke’s Son of the Godhead theory or Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard’s theory of Lord Xenu ruling the world.
— location: 339 ^ref-16748
MICE explains the main motivators for covert and overt action. It stands for Money, Ideology, Compromise, and Ego
— location: 822 ^ref-50903
MICE explains the main motivators for covert and overt action. It stands for Money, Ideology, Compromise, and Ego.
— location: 822 ^ref-52230
These days people who work to benefit a foreign actor are often called “useful idiots”; a term often falsely attributed to Vladimir Lenin.51 I find it counterproductive to refer to these people as idiots, as some are quite intelligent and have simply chosen to profit from working for the enemy.
— location: 832 ^ref-40979
1997: Russia and Ukraine agree to divide the Black Sea Fleet in a partition treaty. Ukraine agrees to lease its Crimean naval facilities to Russia until 2017 in exchange for an annual $97 million fee paid in gas and a Russian pledge to “respect the sovereignty of Ukraine”. Unanimously terminated by the Russian Parliament in 2014 following the annexation of Crimea.
— location: 1272 ^ref-46386
In February 2013, the Verkhovna Rada, Ukraine’s parliament, had overwhelmingly approved – 315 of 349 MPs voted “Yes” – the implementation of Ukraine’s aspirations for European integration and the signing of the EU-Ukraine Association Agreement.
— location: 1348 ^ref-13278
further. In rural Russia, approximately two-thirds have no access to indoor toilets. As with everything in Russia, this also highlights the contrast between the major cities and rural areas.
— location: 1569 ^ref-43251
According to surveys, 80% of British boys aged 16-17 have seen Andrew’s content, while 45% of British men aged 16-24 held a positive view of him.
— location: 1821 ^ref-13275
These days, Medvedev mainly posts angry rants on social media where he calls for genocide in Ukraine, threatens the West with nuclear and traditional weapons on an almost daily basis, and blames NATO for starting a proxy war. In other words, all the usual vatnik stuff.
— location: 2114 ^ref-30188
Dmitry Peskov has an incredible ability; whenever he says something, the exact opposite seems to happen.
— location: 2128 ^ref-14298
On 15 February, 2022, he stated that the allegations about Russia invading Ukraine were “empty and unfounded” and called it “Western hysteria”. He had previously declared that “Russia has never attacked any other nation”, and that Russia would be “the last country in Europe to think about starting a war”. Peskov concluded that “we’re living in days of fakes and lies”. As we now know, this was the only truth to come out of his mouth that day.
— location: 2129 ^ref-9636
The term Russophobia is largely a Kremlin construct meant to deflect any criticism towards the Russian state’s hostilities and interference with other sovereign countries.
— location: 2617 ^ref-30494
From Jeffrey Sachs’ point of view, the nations that have joined NATO or are planning on doing so should be denied the right to choose for themselves. This line of thinking reduces these countries to mere pawns and buffer states that should defer to imperialist nations ruling an envisioned multipolar world. But for most Eastern European countries, Russia is the reason they joined NATO in the first place. Leaked documents have confirmed that Putin and his Kremlin gang had plans to take over Moldova in addition to Ukraine, while also having designs on the Baltic countries.
— location: 3011 ^ref-19718
The main driver behind John Mearsheimer’s school of thought is an assumption that “great powers” like the US, China and – for some weird reason – Russia are primarily driven by the rational desire to achieve regional hegemony within an anarchic international system.
— location: 3053 ^ref-51738
He believes that Russia had no choice but to invade Ukraine as the West was provoking them with the constant eastward NATO expansion. This view is based on the idea of Realpolitik, where politics is stripped of any moral or ideological considerations. Great powers simply decide what happens to smaller countries that are considered to be part of their sphere of influence. This perspective conveniently denies smaller countries any agency and sovereignty while deferring their fate to others.
— location: 3057 ^ref-35906
In the words of former US Senator John McCain, the country would more aptly be described as a Mafia-run gas station, which completely disregards democracy and human rights.
— location: 3070 ^ref-36498
Mearsheimer has never passed any judgment on the most horrific war crimes committed in Ukraine, including the
— location: 3074 ^ref-27638
From this perspective, it is of little significance whether Russia is run by Stalin, Gorbachev, or Putin, or whether Germany is ruled by Angela Merkel or Adolf Hitler. Incidentally, Mearsheimer has never passed any judgment on the most horrific war crimes committed in Ukraine, including the abduction of Ukrainian children. This becomes a glaring omission since he has criticised Israel heavily on this exact issue in his book The Israel Lobby and US Foreign Policy (2007). In the book, Mearsheimer also refers to a “moral dimension” in the United States’ enabling of Israeli crimes against the Palestinians. It appears that Russia is allowed a little genocidal tendency; the US is not.
— location: 3073 ^ref-7434
Peterson also thinks that Ukraine is “key to Russian identity and security.” In other words, this vatnik is yet another supporter of the “realpolitik” school of thought, which leaves Ukraine without agency of its own. Like other small nations they should let the “big boys” decide their fate.
— location: 3120 ^ref-41073
Russian intelligence agents in the West are often simply losers and rejects who detest their own society for not letting them succeed even though, as they’d be the first to tell you, they had every right to.
— location: 3713 ^ref-23828
Wallace falls into the category “anti-imperialist” – which in a vatnik context means exclusively criticising the US and NATOs on the foreign policy stage.
— location: 3778 ^ref-11121
When Putin left his position as head of the FSB, Patrushev took over the reins. He headed the agency during the poisoning of ex-FSB agent Alexander Litvinenko, and a public inquiry by the UK government concluded that the assassination was “probably approved” by both Putin and him.233 From his British exile, Litvinenko had accused Putin of ordering the assassinations of oligarch Boris Berezovsky (who was killed in 2013) and journalist Anna Politkovskya (killed in 2006),
— location: 3914 ^ref-28351
His criticism of interventionism continued in the 1970s and 1980s, where the US was involved in conflicts like the Nicaraguan Contra War and the Israel-Palestine conflict. Since then, everything he says has been informed by anti-Americanism. Chomsky seems to consider the US the root of all evil. and can turn any topic into US-bashing. In some ways, he is the epitome of a whataboutist.
— location: 3947 ^ref-60503
While preaching a life of modesty and spirituality, Kirill doesn’t seem to have paid much attention to his own sermons, as he is also a billionaire whose wealth is estimated at around $4 billion. This obscene fortune was likely amassed through supplying foreign cigarettes to Russia.
— location: 4113 ^ref-46705
When you look at Paul Manafort’s life, it seems that most of it has been dedicated to making the world a worse place.
— location: 4136 ^ref-2268
Manafort has been involved with lobbying across the globe and seems to have been willing to work for anyone if the money was good. His lobbying portfolio includes Angolan rebel leader Jonas Savimbi, Saudi Arabia, Congolese dictator Mobutu Sese Seko, and Filipino dictator and kleptocrat Ferdinand Marcos. For his work with the Marcos regime, his company earned $950,000 annually. Marcos’s reign was infamous for its brutality and corruption — and was later revealed to have stolen between $5–10 billion from the Central Bank of the Philippines. Manafort’s hard work eventually got his lobbying firm on the Center for Public Integrity’s top 5 lobbying firms receiving money from regimes abusing human rights.
— location: 4139 ^ref-42015
The Chechen Republic under Kadyrov rule has mainly been held together by federal subsidies, although most of the money never reaches the people, instead lining the pockets of Kadyrov and his fellow warlords.
— location: 4179 ^ref-51177
Even though Wagenknecht has spent most of her career in leftist parties, her political views and statements don’t really fit this shoe, but rather the shape of a horseshoe. In Germany, there is even a term for this: Querfront (cross-front). Closer examination of Wagenknecht’s views on immigration, her comments on Russia and even her economical views reveal that her ideology is often far more compatible with a far-right mindset than any leftist policies.
— location: 4537 ^ref-6434
While her speeches may have been applauded by (other) far-right politicians, Wagenknecht’s pro-Kremlin views caused a rift within Die Linke. 50 party members applied for her resignation in October 2023, and Wagenknecht announced that she was forming a new party, revealed in January 2024 as the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance – Reason and Justice (BSW).
— location: 4558 ^ref-16375
So, why has Hersh devolved from a price-winning reporter to a sloppy fiction writer? Perhaps he wants to stay relevant, or maybe money plays a part? We can only speculate. Either way, Hersh should realise that his dis- and misinformation-riddled pieces are used as propaganda tools. Following his spy novel/article, Russia requested a UNSC meeting over the Nord Stream sabotage.
— location: 4826 ^ref-3237
Berlusconi was also the controlling shareholder of Italy’s largest commercial broadcaster, Mediaset. According to The Economist – or The Ecommunist, as Berlusconi called it – he controlled 90% of all national broadcasting in Italy while also being the prime minister.303 Some might consider that a minor conflict of interest.
— location: 4834 ^ref-59532
far-right parties in Europe – many of which have politicians with their own Vatnik Soups – including FPÖ (Austria), UKIP/Reform (Great Britain), AfD (Germany), Lega Nord (Italy), Fidesz (Hungary), Vox (Spain), SVP (Switzerland), and National Rally (France).
— location: 4914 ^ref-49553
In November 2022, Orbán wore a football scarf with a map of Greater Hungary, which greatly angered both Romania and Ukraine.
— location: 5237 ^ref-50802
Solovyov’s primary purpose is to get people riled up about the war and the “brutal Ukrainians”. Solovyov employs a powerful strategy: He’s one of the few people who is allowed to criticise the Russian leadership and their decisions on the war. This doesn’t apply to Putin of course, who is above such petty criticisms. A Russian saying that dates to the era of Peter the Great can help explain this dynamic: Tsar khoroshiy, boyare plokhiye, which translates to Good Tsar, Bad Boyars. This allows Putin to deflect blame to the lower echelons of power — and Solovyov plays his part to perfection.
— location: 5377 ^ref-43855